Survivor 34 Episode 12 “No Good Deed Goes Unpunished”

Well, as far as Survivor goes, that’s a wrap!

The season ended tonight and, in the post below, I’m going to be revealing who was in the final three and who won.  It should go without saying that, if you haven’t watched the finale yet, this post is a huge spoiler so don’t read any further unless you’re okay with finding out who won.

As you may remember, I predicted that our final three would be Aubry, Tai, and Troyzan.  I thought there was no way that Brad would be able to win enough immunity challenges to avoid being voted out.  I was sure Cirie would be targeted and voted out.  I thought there was no way that anyone would be stupid enough to take Sarah to the end.  I figured that Troyzan, being the most likable of my projected final three, would win by default.

Well, I was right that Troyzan would make it to the final three but otherwise, I was totally wrong.  Brad won all three of tonight’s immunity challenges, guaranteeing himself a place in the final three.

At the first tribal on the night, Tai used one immunity idol on himself and the other on Aubry.  Sarah revealed that she had a legacy advantage, which meant she had immunity.  Troyzan played his idol.  Culpepper already had immunity from winning the challenge.  That meant that Cirie was the only person who didn’t have immunity and, as a result, she was voted out of the tribe despite the fact that no one had voted her.

The vote, by the way, was three for Sarah, two for Tai, and one for Aubry.  If Tai had not used his other idol on Aubry, she would have been voted out by one vote. Instead, Ciririe was voted out despite getting no votes.

(Incidentally, that seems amazingly unfair and I imagine the rules will change in the future.)

That was pretty much the most exciting part of the finale.  The rest, other than Culpepper’s challenge streak, was predictable.  Aubry was voted out at the next tribal.  After that, Tai was voted out because Culpepper wanted revenge for all the times that he felt Tai had betrayed him.

(Culpepper appeared to be obsessed with not only voting out Tai but humiliating him as well.  It was not pleasant to listen to.)

The final tribal council was different for what I’m used to and I’m not sure I cared much for the new format.  Now, instead of the jurors asking questions, the jurors discussed who had best lived up to the Survivor motto of “Outwit, Outplay, Outlast.”  The final three get to take part in the discussion and each got to make a final statement.  It felt a little silly, to be honest but then again, the juror questions were rarely that interesting either.

Anyway, the jurors agreed that Brad had played a good physical game but that Sarah played an all-around better social and strategic game.  I thought that Troyzan might win some votes based on his being more likable than either Brad or Sarah but it didn’t happen that way.  (Troyzan, it must be said, figured out early that he wasn’t going to get any votes and he handled it far better than most third place finishers.)  Sarah won by a 7-3 vote.

During the reunion, it was revealed that, if Brad had brought Tai into the final three, he would have actually won.  The jury would have voted 5-5, at which point Troyzan — having the least number of votes — would have become a juror and he would have cast his vote for Brad.

As for the rest of the reunion, it was okay.  Sarah is not exactly the most likable person to ever win Survivor so it was hard to get too excited over her victory.  I do prefer her winning over Brad, if just because Brad had a tendency to be a bully and that really got on my nerves.  Jeff Probst perhaps realized this because he spent most of the reunion talking to Cirie and Zeke.  He also talked to Jeff Varner, who came across as being just as smarmy as ever.

And so, another season of Survivor comes to a close!  What did everyone think of the finale?  Who would you have preferred to have won?

Lisa Marie


9 thoughts on “Survivor 34 Episode 12 “No Good Deed Goes Unpunished”

  1. jsd412

    Lisa, I agree about the discussion vs questions but questions were still asked. I didn’t like how the jury was trying to sell one over the other. I’m glad Sarah won. This game is lying and backstabbing and she did it great and wasn’t nasty. Dirty maybe, but that’s the game. Brad did the only thing he could do to stay in the game and Troyzan rode his coattail. I would have liked to see Tai in the final 3 but there was no way Sara could do his plan over guaranteeing her in the final 3. Sad to see it end. Here comes Big Brother and Survivor will be back in no time.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Sammi O'Leary

    I didn’t want any of the three to win but definitely Sarah over Brad. I hated Brad’s bullying tonight. I really hated it and was upset that there wasn’t a long discussion on it. I’ve never liked Brad.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Deb

    Thanks for the recap Lisa Marie. You did a great job all season. I was pulling for Sarah and I’m glad she won. Something about Brad rubbed me the wrong way all season and the last few episodes proved me right. He must have felt like a big man picking on Tai. I thought Aubry’s plan for her, Sarah and Tai to vote out Troyzan was a good one. Troyzan realized early that he had no chance and handled it well. I think the best part of the reunion show was not hearing a peep from Debbie.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Julia M Rohrs

    I thought this was a good season, however I would have preferred an Ozzy win over these 3 or Tai. Anyway….now on to Big Brother and before you know it back on to another season of Survivor!


  5. Keith E. Benton

    The jury made the right choice giving the win to Sara, as she played the best all around game. So many people on Survivor Facebook seem to think that this game is an athletic one and the best at challenges deserve to win, but that is just one facet of the game. Brad didn’t have any strategy that worked and physical competition is all he had to go on. Troyzan was the obligatory coat tail rider this season and it’s no surprise that he finished third, since they never win. I won’t say this is the best season, but it was entertaining. I didn’t care for the new jury q&a format, which reminded me of how BB does their jury, or at least how they used to do it.

    As far as Cirie goes, that’s just how the cookie crumbles and she should’ve been looking for an idol early on in the game. Personally I think they have gone overboard with hidden immunity idols and advantages and it takes away from the scheming and strategy of the game imo.


  6. theycallmetater

    I was underwhelmed by the finale and the final 6. I feel like the show would have been much better had some of the early outcasts been around. I feel the season suffered because people like Tony, Malcolm and Sandra were not around very long.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Karlla

    This was probably the worst season EVER! I watched each week and complained to myself for wasting an hour. All the crazy changes were ridiculous and I didn’t see where they made the show more interesting this season.
    I was not a fan of Brad or Sarah…Troyzan “floating” to the win would have been fine with me.
    I did like Malcolm and was sorry to see him go early in the game.
    That new “do” on Ozzy is just the worst ever!?!
    I actually wanted Cirie to win. I thought the way she left was jacked up!
    I commend you (again) Lisa for doing a great job each week!



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.